The Upper Tribunal (UT) has refused a scaffolding contractor permission to appeal against a VAT assessment raised against it by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC).
The contractor was based in Northern Ireland. It used plastic sheeting as a 'wrap around' for buildings under construction. The Commissioners in the Republic of Ireland had provided HMRC with five invoices issued to a company there by the contractor, relating to the supply of plastic sheeting. Those transactions had been omitted from the contractor's VAT return but the contractor said that, as they were supplies to the Republic of Ireland, they were zero rated and so the overall VAT position remained the same.
The contractor sent HMRC five tachograph cards as evidence that the plastic sheeting had been removed from the UK. However, HMRC took the view that the contractor had not kept sufficient evidence to prove that the goods had been exported to the Republic of Ireland and issued a VAT assessment of £63,600. The contractor's appeal against that decision was dismissed by the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) on the basis that the statutory conditions for issuing a VAT assessment set out in Section 73 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 had been satisfied, including best judgment and the related time limits.
The contractor sought permission to appeal to the UT on the basis that the FTT should have found that the assessment had not been made within one year after evidence of facts sufficient in the opinion of HMRC to justify the making of the assessment had come to their knowledge, as required by Section 73(6)(b) of the Act.
The contractor argued that HMRC had based the assessment on the invoices, which they had held since June 2020, and it would have been clear to them at or around the same time that those sales had not been entered into the contractor's VAT return, but they had failed to act until November 2022. However, the UT found that it was plainly neither perverse nor unreasonable for HMRC to decide that they did not have adequate evidence to make an assessment until they had sought information about the contractor's case that the goods had been exported, and considered information supplied to them by the contractor.
The contractor also contended that the FTT had failed to properly apply Section 73(6)(b). It claimed that the FTT had misstated the statutory test, which is not whether HMRC are entitled to ask for further information: instead, they are required to assess within one year of receiving the last piece of evidence. However, the FTT had expressly determined that the last piece of evidence was the tachographs, which HMRC had received two days before the assessment was issued. It was not reasonably arguable that the FTT had failed to identify and apply the statutory test. Permission to appeal was refused.







